Cloud Save Method (Console/Game Pass) At the very bottom! Get 2 out of 3 endings in 1 playthrough! Read through the guide carefully and have a look at the comments for the best insight! I can not provide any assistance if it does not work. Important Note from WhyattThrash - The game does perform periodic cloud uploads without user interaction. The safest way to go for the achievements are to 1) try offline or 2) go about it real fast if offline doesn’t work, but be aware that might lead to the game uploading a save on its own and there’s not much to be done about it.Here's a guide for all lie/truth choices/gaining humanity in the game, Created by WhyattThrash - Telling truth/lies scenarios and gaining Humanity (SPOILERS)Xbox FAQ on how cloud saves work - https://support.xbox.com/en-US/help/games-apps/game-setup-an...After beating the "final" boss Simon Manus in Chapter 11, you will meet with Geppetto. He wants you to give him your heart, and you have two choices, "refuse" or "Give the Heart". To get this ending you must give Geppetto your heart. Your choices of telling the truth or lies throughout the game do not matter for this ending, and will only take effect if you refuse to give your heart.
Don't go into New Game+ after the credits. Doing this ending will also give you an additional achievement! Don't restart your game to return to Hotel Krat, and read the note at Geppetto's desk.
Additionally, if you're on your Lie/Humanity playthrough -
Interact with the portrait to get the Golden Lie special weapon
If you refuse, you will fight the true final boss "Nameless Puppet", and will get the ending based on if you -Mostly lied ("Rise of P")
Mostly told the truth ("Free of the Puppet Strings").
Cloud Save Method (Console only) - By doing this method you can get 2 endings in 1 playthrough! You can get
"Real Boy" by giving Geppetto your heart, AND either
"Rise of P" or
"Free of the Puppet Strings" by refusing depending on your truth and lie choices throughout the game.
Offline tip by chris8079 - For anyone who doesn't wanna risk messing up, you can just make sure you save uploads and then go offline before getting this achievement. Afterwards, just delete your save and go back online to sync it back up before fighting the nameless puppet.
Cloud Save Method used by Gotham Rises - MAKE SURE YOUR GAME IS RUNNING after you get your final achievement for whatever you're doing > hit Xbox button > hover Lies of P > Menu button > Manage game > Saved data > Click your gamertag > Delete from console > Resume Lies of P. You should then be forced to load the game back to the main menu, just hit continue, and you should be back at wherever you made your cloud save. Literally just worked for me. If you've played a From Software game, you've done this before..
Cloud Save Method used by FrankCastle492 - Sit at the Stargazer before speaking to Geppetto.
-Quit your game (On the dashboard) so your save uploads to the cloud.
-Start the game up again, and give him your heart, then after the credits you can get the letter from his study to complete his story.
-After that stand still and press the guide button, highlight the game and press start, go to manage add-ons, go to saved data, and delete your save from the console only this will force close the game.
-When you load up the game, it will download your cloud save, and you'll be back at the Stargazer before Geppetto and can do one of the other two endings.
Cloud Save Method used by MiNDmaZing - Sat at the stargazer, Exit the game for a cloud save
loaded up, refused heart -> beat nameless pupped, trade ergo for weapon
listened to 1 song fully to get full humanity -> read the letter on table ->
took golden lie from the picture
Afterwards i deleted the profile from console and the game forced a quit. cloud save downloaded and i could give heart -> read letter from table and played the piano