This is best done using two controllers.
Mode: Exhibition
Teamsize: 1v1
- No bots
Mutator settings:
- Match Length: 5 minutes
- Max Score: unlimited
Using the second controller, score a goal making it 1-0. Wait until the clock is under 60 seconds and with the first controller, score two goals making it 2-1. Then just let the timer run and the achievement will unlock.